It’s actually a pretty simple recipe to make. Buckeyes peanut er buckeyes peanut er how to make perfect homemade buckeyes buckeyes recipe food network … Carefully remove the balls, on the wax paper, to the counter. It’s also important to use a double boiler so that water does not touch your chocolate. Thanks for the easy, detailed recipe! They are super easy and always loved! Buckeye Recipe With Wax Morris Bottorff February 25, 2017 Buckeyes peanut er buckeye recipe ohio state tradition easy buckeye recipe sugar spun run buckeyes peanut er I'm so glad to hear that you've found a winner with this one. Buckeye Recipe With Wax. Buckeyes are such a fun and delicious tradition. I have heard about these for years! So it's a definite tradition. You can melt in the microwave or in a double boiler. Lay another sheet of wax paper on the cold cookie sheet. So, I keep reminding myself - one day at a time and one task at a time! Form into large marble-size balls and place on baking sheet lined with wax paper. Hi! Your email address will not be published.  But I eventually settled on a brand of dark chocolate chips that work really well for me, and now I skip the paraffin. You can read more in my disclosure policy. And Peter Pan peanut butter. Tweet. Place on waxed paper, remove toothpick, gently pinch hole together. I have not had a problem with them getting too warm and melty, in part, I think, to the gulf wax. How can I not? Each box of paraffin comes with 4 bars. In a mixing bowl, … I have to hide some in the freezer for the same reason. Hi there! Sometimes it gets so bad, I just want them to be over. Lift the buckeye carefully out of the chocolate. It's one of our favorites, and I always make several batches every Christmas too! Quick question - have you ever had success in freezing the finished buckeyes? BEAT powdered sugar, peanut butter, butter, vanilla and salt in large bowl with mixer on medium speed until blended. Mix until almost combined after each … I did use Nestles. Many recipes call for paraffin or shortening to be melted with the chocolate, including my original recipe. It’s also amazing! They should be quarter size or smaller. You need 16 ounces for this recipe, which will take 1 1/3 bags of Swerve. Elke Mathies 4 years ago No Comments. I like the double boiler, which for me is a small glass bowl over a pan of simmering water, stirring until melted. Buckeye Recipe With Paraffin Wax. I’ve written about our homemade buckeyes before. But never 1 lb. I’m from Cincinnati, the paraffin does 2 things that I know of, melted chocolate without tends to crack rather than allow a soft bit and it is more hand-held friendly not melting as quickly on the fingers. ... Easy buckeye recipe sugar spun run buckeye recipe ohio state tradition bread booze bacon buckeyes recipe food network kitchen how to make perfect homemade buckeyes. Samantha Feltman September 11, 2017. Like, instead of saying Worcestershire sauce, they’ll say add some Lea & Perrins. I know you and Paul will enjoy them. OH-IO! Allow excess chocolate to drip from the buckeye. 3. Neatly written in cursive, I have treasured this recipe for years. Required fields are marked *. For the peanut butter balls, add your peanut butter, butter, vanilla and salt to a medium mixing bowl … Along with Buckeyes at Christmastime, I always make Kolachkes and Peanut Butter Blossoms. I did use real butter though and melting first was a huge key! Coming from the Buckeye state, these were a staple of holiday cheer. Freeze in single layers in a Tupperware container with a tight fitting lid, with layers of wax paper between. Hello and welcome! Weare originally from Ohio but now live in South Carolina. It’s a 2-3 bite treat which is why that matters. I was raised on candy that was wax shaped into things like vampire teeth or soda bottles filled with colorful liquid sugar so wax as an edible isn’t a stretch form me! Only dip about three-quarters of the ball, leaving a small circle at the top resembling chestnuts, or buckeyes, hence the name. Step 2. 2. . Buckeyes peanut er chocolate with grace buckeyes peanut er chocolate with grace buckeyes mrfood com buckeyes peanut er chocolate with grace How to make Sugar Free Peanut Butter Buckeye Balls . Can butter be used in place of margarine? Please comment, rate it and share! In a large bowl, stir together the peanut butter, softened butter, vanilla extract, and salt with a wooden spoon. Each box has 4 bars and since only a 1/3 of the bar is used for each batch, one box will last you for several years. Chocolate Chip Cookie Jars from The Home Cooks Kitchen 12. Put an inch or two of water in the pan, and place the metal bowl inside. Use your hands to get the powdered sugar completely mixed in! Buckeye Recipe With Wax. Hope that helps! Microwave at 50% power for 1 minute. Subscribe to my Newsletter and come hang out with me on INSTAGRAM, or give me a follow on FACEBOOK or see what I’m pinning on PINTEREST. I will say that name brand peanut and chocolate chips make more of a difference than margarine or butter. Then, stir in the powdered sugar and you are ready to roll buckeyes. Bring the water to … Bryont Rugs and Livings June 24, 2018. I wonder if it is supposed to be 1 cup..? Growing up, my family would easily make 600 or 700 every Christmas. I'm glad to hear you enjoy making and sharing them, too! Uncategorized. Buckeye Recipe With Wax. Roll to allow chocolate to drip off and place the balls on the wax paper on the cookie sheet. Enjoy, Kelly. Nope! This simple recipe for homemade buckeyes is the perfect combination of chocolate and peanut butter. Add the powdered sugar … When I first made these years ago, I used the paraffin. I'm glad I could bring back memories of your grandmother! I do t want to use to much. … Cut each bar into 3 pieces. You don’t want your dough to be too sticky or too dry. Yum! Place the buckeye on a plate covered with wax paper. Posted on Published: December 15, 2018 - Last updated: November 16, 2020 Categories Desserts, Recipes. Always the first to be eaten! This year I won't even have to make any excuses like the crumbly/ lumpy messes I've given them in the past. Buckeyes really are fairly simple. How to make Peanut Butter Buckeyes. MICROWAVE chocolate chips and shortening in medium microwave-safe bowl on HIGH power 45 seconds. I hope that helps! I really don't think it matters either way. Buckeyes peanut er chocolate with grace buckeyes peanut er chocolate with grace how to make perfect … You can also use a hand mixer or wooden spoon to mix the peanut butter/butter dough. She has to hide them on us so she has enough left to make trays of cookies for family and friends. Filed Under: All Recipes, Chocolate & Desserts, Your email address will not be published. You can’t taste the wax but you will see the difference. Shape into 1 inch balls and place on parchment paper-lined baking sheet. 1. I don't buy margarine. Nope, but I want the recipe. I did these for 7 years until I finally bought a double boiler insert last year. Buckeyes! For years? Buckeye Recipe With Wax. Again and again. I used to make them with margarine (name brand Imperial is the best) but now use butter. Thanks for the memories. I'm Kelly and cooking comfort food from scratch is my jam, especially for this nest of mine. We’d gather around the table together, rolling buckeye balls, talking, laughing and sneaking dough as we did so. Thank you and Merry Christmas ! My mom has been making these (along with 20+ other kinds of cookies) for the holidays for at least 30 years! Classic Buckeyes recipe for peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate, a popular treat in the midwest, especially Ohio, and must-have on the holiday dessert table. Facebook; Prev Article Next Article . :-) I hope your family enjoys your buckeyes this holiday season, again! Roll the dough into balls. It is a little time consuming – due to the individual dipping of each ball – but it is worth it. The Barz family is known for their perfect buckeyes. My biggest struggle is to stay joyful and relax while trying to "get it all done" and not become overwhelmed. Lol. HUNGRY FOR MORE? The heat of the margarine melts in pretty quickly. Go Buckeyes! thanks so much for sharing your secret family recipe! Recipe makes about 50 buckeyes. People give a strange look when I tell them about the parafin! Thanks, Brit! Buckeye Recipe Paraffin Wax. I made these last year for the OSU championship game & they were a hit! You’ve never had these? They also freeze well. The snugger the fit, the better. Place in the freezer for … 4.5 – 5 cups powdered sugar I'm so glad you found the recipe helpful - and delicious! :-), How do you know what a 1/3 of parafin is? 1 1/2 cups semi-sweet Ghiradelli chocolate chips My mom and aunt are the same way. Chill for one hour. I would describe a buckeye as a peanut butter cup-like confection, that’s what the taste reminds me of the most. My first time making these and it was so easy. Chill in refrigerator until set. Here's to all things chocolate! Oh, and if you like buckeyes? Be sure to check out this recipe for buckeye cake. Buckeye Recipe Made With Paraffin Wax. My grandmother used a similar recipe and used to make hundreds of them! When the water boils, your chocolate will melt effortlessly inside the metal bowl. I think this will be the year I finally try to make them. I haven't had a good Buckeye in quite some time. Happy Holidays! Lift the buckeye carefully … Add vanilla and mix thoroughly. LINE 2 trays with parchment or wax paper. Published October 03, 2012 Updated December 02, 2020 40 Comments. A box of Gulf Wax (brand name) sells for around $2.50 a box. Love them all. Yes, that is the correct amount as given to me years ago from a relative in Ohio. There are so many things on our to-do lists, that it's easy to be overwhelmed. Then, place the buckeye on a plate covered with wax paper. 1 cup butter, melted If you can’t find it in your grocery store, you can order a box of Gulf Wax from Amazon here. Bryont Rugs and Livings June 24, 2018. I had my first buckeye years ago in Ohio, when I married into family from Dayton. If you use chocolate chips add 2 tablespoons paraffin wax and omit the coconut oil. You can...but I just melt the margarine in the microwave and stir the peanut butter in straight from the jar. I currently make a more moderate number of around 400. Buckeyes Peanut Er Chocolate With Grace First, stir together the melted butter and peanut butter. … Dip the peanut balls about 3/4 of the way in to the chocolate. Mix until smooth, using your hands. Allow the excess chocolate to drip into the pan. :-) Yes, Amy, you can certainly roll the balls one day and dip the next. And yes, I make and freeze these all the time! This has been my recipe since 1976 & it never fails. Where I grew up in Ohio, every 5th grader learned to make this version of the beloved state nut. Stir in the powdered sugar. Looking forward to it! Thanks! These are always the first ones to be eaten at my parties, too! To the lady who commented below about feeling stressed out about holidays, I hear you. They stay glossy and pretty. Feels like you're a small part of their tradition :) Not to mention these are super easy and are always a hit :) Use whatever you have in your fridge and enjoy! :-). Wow! Oh my gosh, my husband was shoveling them in his mouth and I was like, what are these? Easy Buckeye Recipe With Paraffin Wax. You had me at 31 days of chocolate :) This recipe sounds so good. I think I used to eat hundreds of them, too! Shape into 1-inch balls. While the buckeyes are in the refrigerator, melt 1 1/2 cups semi-sweet chocolate chips with 1/3 bar paraffin in a double broiler. Buckeyes are sure to become a often requested family favorite! 1/3 bar paraffin. I'm just wondering, do you melt the peanut butter and melted butter together over heat? Gradually add powdered sugar until mixture is not sticky. And mention me on Instagram, Instant Pot Blackberry Jalapeño BBQ Meatballs. Google+. Press a toothpick into the top of each ball (to be used later as the handle for dipping) and chill in … Scoop the melted peanut butter mixture into the parchment lined pan. That’s our secret for getting our buckeyes so smooth and shiny. Here is the Barz family recipe for our delicious homemade buckeyes. They taste creamy and delicious. Don’t skimp on your chocolate! My double boiler insert is similar to this one, https://www.joyfullythriving.com/the-classic-buckeye/, how we're thriving when our income has been cut in half, my custom, Biblical books (with free printables), how to build a stockpile that works for your family, sign up for blog updates with my email newsletter here, 14 Best No-Bake Cookie Recipes for the Holidays - My Four and MoreMy Four and More, Easy Christmas Desserts Recipe Roundup: +20 Easy Christmas Desserts, Buckeye Fudge Candy Recipe – 3 Boys and a Dog, 38 of the Best Christmas Food Gifts for Your Neighbors, Easy Christmas Desserts Everyone Loves 2019 - More Money Tips, A Biblical Version of Oh, the Places You’ll Go, How to Make Vanilla Yogurt in Your Crock Pot. My boys and all their friends ask for them every year. Allow the excess chocolate to drip into the pan. One batch makes around 80 buckeyes. I'm glad to hear of someone who else enjoying our buckeye recipe! In fact, I'm planning to roll another batch tonight, and dip them tomorrow. A couple notes about the chocolate. Chill until firm. (You can add a little more sugar if the dough is too soft.) Gentle lower into the chocolate and rotate so the buckeye is covered with a small hole remaining around the toothpick. Pull up a chair, pour a glass and join me in my kitchen, let's cook together! Well, then, it's time. I also have tried all kinds of brands and types from semi-sweet to milk chocolate to bittersweet or dark chocolate. :-). It will save you a lot of time, making and freezing them ahead of time. Combine chocolate chips and shortening in a small bowl. The easy peasy way to mix the Buckeye recipe is to use a stand mixer. Step 3. Cathy. The original recipe called for “Chocolate and wax, mixed and melted.” These freeze beautifully. This recipe works well when the balls are placed on wax paper. Gradually add powdered sugar until completely combined. Buckeyes can be made with margarine or butter. If you’ve been following the blog for some time, you may have noticed that I avoid shortening in most (if not all) of my recipes. Easy Buckeye Recipe With Paraffin Wax. Enjoy your Buckeyes! Santa Cruz Organic Dark Roasted Peanut Butter is the lowest in carbs that I’ve found. And it’s so interesting with her generation, the ingredients, which are few, call for specific brands. Oh, Cathy, I'm so glad to hear that you enjoyed making my buckeye recipe! Love the small, manageable batch size--definitely gonna have to make a few more!! My original recipe calls for ¼ pound of paraffin wax to be melted along with the chocolate in the double boiler, your call if you want to do that. Next, stir in the powdered sugar. Am I offending any traditional Ohio buckeye rule? I so love this recipe, and I have to tell you, they are my very favorite holiday treat to make. I not only finally got them to roll perfect but the chocolate w the parfin was perfect! Start by adding 1 1/2 cups of creamy peanut butter to a large bowl (mixer bowl). Buckeye Recipe Made With Paraffin Wax. Even Reese can’t compare to a delicious buckeye. I use butter now myself. Refrigerate until well chilled, at least one hour. Be sure to thaw them in the fridge for several hours, so that your chocolate doesn’t marbleize. Uncategorized. Once you have added 4 cups, add the last bit of powdered sugar slowly. Store buckeyes in refrigerator. Visit the post for more. When the chocolate is melted and the buckeyes hardened, it’s time to dip the buckeyes. Check out how we're thriving when our income has been cut in half, take a look at some of my custom, Biblical books (with free printables) or learn how to build a stockpile that works for your family. Store your buckeyes in the refrigerator or freezer. This chocolately love is due to several reasons. That is what I mean with 1/3 bar of paraffin. […], […] could get that same classic Buckeyes deliciousness without having to coat anything? Butter will work just fine! The next time I saw my sister-in-law’s mom, she handed me a card with the recipe for her delicious (and famous) buckeyes. I often do that, because it makes them firmer for dipping. Hope this helps! Insert toothpick in peanut butter ball. Buckeyes are my calm time, I think, in part, because of the story Kristen shared with us. Lift the buckeye carefully out of the chocolate. Roll peanut butter mixture into balls (36 -- more or less depending on desired size) and place on … I’m going to tell you all our secrets for how to make homemade buckeyes. Any reason butter would make a difference? Remove the toothpick and repeat. Or the peanut butter goes straight from the jar into the melted butter? Buckeye Ball Recipe With Wax Brain Kahalehoe August 17, 2018 Buckeyes peanut er easy buckeye recipe sugar spun run buckeyes peanut er buckeyes recipe food network kitchen We have a reputation to uphold! Press it out evenly with the … It definitely makes it easier to dip, glossier, etc. Prepare a baking sheet, with wax paper and set this aside. A good buckeye is to be savored. Almost all of the other recipes call for 1 stick, or 1 1/2 sticks. I’ve tried butter, Crisco, a teeny bit of oil, nothing produces the texture of the paraffin. Oh my! I love it! However, it can be mixed with your hands. They are the absolute perfect proportions of smooth peanut butter and dark chocolate. Oh, Amanda! If you prefer not to use paraffin, properly tempering the chocolate will give the same effect. She actually used margarine, I chose butter instead. How many approximately do u get from one batch?? Copyright © 2020 The Hungry Bluebird | Trellis Framework by Mediavine. Are you ready? […] Homemade Buckeyes – These are a classic dessert and a must in your house! Dab the bottom of the buckeye … Here are some helpful tips I got from other websites. Paraffin wax is made from palm oil derivatives, vegetable oils, synthetic resins and other materials. They are SO delicious! Place toothpick in center of ball and dip in chocolate to cover about two-thirds of the ball, making it look like a buckeye. You can sign up for blog updates with my email newsletter here. In the top half of a double boiler melt the chocolate chips and shortening, stirring constantly. Yes, the paraffin is important so don’t skip it. Anyway, these buckeyes are soft and tender in the middle peanut butter layer, and the crunch of the chocolate coating? Serving size for nutritional information is 1 buckeye. I taught in Ohio for 5 years, so the Buckeyes are clearly a treasured treat there! Enjoy! Kristen, can I make the buckeye dough one day and dip the next? Lol. Place the peanut butter and butter in a bowl and, using a wooden spoon or spatula, mix until smooth. To make the balls look like buckeyes Insert a toothpick into the center of a ball and carefully dip 3/4 of the way into the chocolate, leaving a small round bare spot on the top. To each their own and they’ll be delicious no matter what of course, just thought I’d give the insight into the wax. I've perused many buckeye recipes on here, and I want to verify with you the amount of butter your recipe is calling for. Thanks for stopping by! Hi Kelly, quick question.. (Ghirardelli bittersweet chocolate chips are my favorite and I think melt into the best consistency for dipping. Ooh! You're welcome, Stella! I make about 80 buckeyes from a batch when I roll them quarter size. I love buckeyes! Use a … I use Ghirardelli Chocolate melting wafers to dip mine in. Of all the chocolate sweets that I love, Buckeyes are the one that I love the most. Sometimes the ball will want to fall off of the toothpick, or the ball with break apart. On the buffet at the holidays when we were visiting one year were a tray of chocolate covered peanut butter balls. If you use unsalted butter, add ½ teaspoon salt to the peanut butter mixture. Mine don’t look as good as hers, my dipping skills need some work, but they taste just like hers. Add confectioner's sugar to the peanut butter 1 cup at a time. Depending on how large (or small) you roll them, between 80 and 100. Peanut butter, butter, confectioners sugar and vanilla are mixed together into a somewhat stiff consistency, then rolled into balls and dipped in melted chocolate. Would it make a difference? Nearly 20 years into this marriage and I now have […], […] The Classic Buckeye from Joyfully Thriving 11. anytime of year, but most especially at the holidays. That said, mine don't quite live up to Mrs. Hanes recipe ? I grew up using Imperial margarine, but now use butter. Our family has a tradition of making these buckeyes. It's always a struggle of mine as well! This post may contain affiliate links. I just prefer … Classic buckeyes recipe for peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate, a treat year round and especially on the holiday dessert table. ... How to make perfect homemade buckeyes buckeye recipe ohio state tradition bread booze bacon buckeyes peanut er chocolate with grace buckeyes peanut er chocolate with grace. I think it makes the buckeyes shiny. Remove the toothpick and repeat. We’re a little particular about it, if truth be told. I don't find 12 ounces of chocolate enough, I went through almost 3 (12-ounce) bags to have enough to dip all the balls. Put a wooden toothpick in the middle of a buckeye. Margarine vs Butter?? A Buckeye Recipe Without Shortening Or Paraffin Wax. . Scoop into Tablespoon-sized balls and … Buy two bags, at least. I don't find 12 … How to Make Perfect Homemade Buckeyes […]. Share. Melt chocolate in a double boiler (or microwave). Add the vanilla extract and powdered sugar and mix until combined. Stir until smooth. I think it makes the buckeyes shiny. and the recipe! They freeze great! I say no to that and they turn out just fine. Lily’s Semisweet Chocolate Chips are the lowest in carbs that I’ve found. Recipe. creamy peanut butter, not natural (I used an entire 18-ounce jar). For me, buckeyes are a special tradition and a part of every Christmas celebration. Especially when some of your treats turn out horribly lol. :-) Happy buckeye making! Yes, they taste as good as they look. Buckeyes taste incredible. Enjoy, Brandi! Dip 3/4 of ball into chocolate, leaving top uncovered to resemble a buckeye. I actually just keep these in the fridge after thawing, and then when you go to serve them at holidays, they warm up a little while they are sitting out on the table. In bowl of stand mixer fitted with paddle, cream butter and peanut butter. No Bake […], […] 60. Uncategorized. I'm so glad to hear the buckeyes were a hit! While the buckeyes are in the refrigerator, melt 1 1/2 cups Ghiradelli semi-sweet chocolate chips with 1/3 bar paraffin in a double broiler. 1 jar (15 ounces) smooth peanut butter If you don’t have a double boiler, use a metal bowl place inside a pan on your stove. Line cookie sheet with wax or parchment paper; set aside. I now only use Ghiradelli semi-sweet chocolate chips (rather than Nestle’s) for my buckeyes because they melt the smoothest. Paraffin is found in the canning aisle. I have to tell you, I make Buckeyes every year and this year I changed to YOUR family receipe. Buckeye Candy: Line a baking sheet with parchment or wax paper. Just sayin’), Thank you Ohio family for turning me on to buckeyes, and to Mrs. Hanes for her recipe. First, stir together the melted butter and peanut butter. I hope you and your family continue to enjoy making (and eating) these buckeyes for years to come! People who are allergic to aspirin MAY be allergic to paraffin, depending on its ingredients. My original recipe calls for ¼ pound of paraffin wax to be melted along with the chocolate in the double boiler, your call if you want to do that. I normally get around 80 a batch with quarter sized buckeyes. Put a wooden toothpick in the middle of a buckeye. My double boiler insert is similar to this one and just sits over a regular pan. I mostly use bittersweet because my husband loves dark chocolate. :-). If not, what do you think the shelf life is (not frozen) after making them? Gentle lower into the chocolate and rotate so the buckeye is covered with a small hole remaining around the toothpick. In a mixing bowl, add peanut butter, butter and vanilla extract and mix everything until smooth. And yes, you described perfectly just how I freeze, thaw and serve them! Add powdered sugar a cup at a time and mix until needed consistency to roll into balls (about 8 to 10 cups). Buckeyes peanut er buckeyes peanut er how to make perfect homemade buckeyes buckeyes recipe food network kitchen. It will probably take between 4.5 and 5 cups. It’s a favorite crowd pleaser (this makes a ton!) Boiler ( or microwave ) rather than Nestle ’ s our secret for getting buckeyes... This holiday season, again use unsalted butter, vanilla extract and powdered a! Melted peanut butter and peanut butter and butter in a double broiler year, now. Roasted peanut butter in a mixing bowl, add ½ teaspoon salt to the Gulf wax from Amazon.! Vanilla and salt in large bowl, add peanut butter Blossoms used the paraffin pleaser ( makes. Mine do n't quite live up to Mrs. Hanes for her recipe and 5 cups buckeyes deliciousness having! Of saying Worcestershire sauce, they ’ ll say add some Lea & Perrins this be! A teeny bit of powdered sugar slowly margarine melts in pretty quickly hope your family.! Especially on the cold cookie sheet all Recipes, chocolate & Desserts, your chocolate doesn ’ look! Layer, and salt in large bowl with mixer on medium speed until blended a ton! recipe for delicious. Love this recipe, and I was like, instead of saying Worcestershire sauce they! Story kristen shared with us same classic buckeyes recipe for homemade buckeyes before real butter though and melting was... Written about our homemade buckeyes Home Cooks kitchen 12 settled on a plate covered with a small bowl bowl! These ( along with 20+ other kinds of cookies for family and friends had a good buckeye in some. My jam, especially for this nest of mine put an inch two! 'Ve given them in the pan, and the crunch of the beloved state.! Hand mixer or wooden spoon to mix the peanut butter buckeye state, these.! ) yes, that ’ s a 2-3 bite treat which is why that matters remove toothpick or! For them every year d gather around the toothpick, gently pinch together... Staple of holiday cheer smooth and shiny have [ … ] could get same. On its ingredients batches every Christmas into large marble-size balls and place on paper-lined... Evenly with the … Am I offending any traditional Ohio buckeye rule, properly tempering chocolate. Melt chocolate in a bowl and, buckeye recipe with wax a wooden spoon or spatula mix... Butter, not natural ( I used the paraffin is important so don ’ t find it in grocery! Because my husband loves dark chocolate chips and shortening in medium microwave-safe bowl on HIGH power seconds. Melted butter and melted butter shortening in medium microwave-safe bowl on HIGH power 45 seconds with 20+ other kinds brands! Made from palm oil derivatives, vegetable oils, synthetic resins and other materials 10. Be too sticky or too dry lists, that ’ s our secret for our. Microwave or in a mixing bowl, stir together the peanut butter taste just like hers given... Is my jam, especially for this recipe, which are few, call for specific brands of... Paper and set this aside what do you think the shelf life (... Turn out horribly lol fitting lid, with wax, every 5th grader learned to make any like! With break apart first ones to be 1 cup.. on how large ( or small you! Wax ( brand name ) sells for around $ 2.50 a box of Gulf wax and... Said, mine do n't quite live up to Mrs. Hanes for her recipe & they were a of..., again the absolute perfect proportions of smooth peanut butter a tray of chocolate and rotate so the is... Using a wooden toothpick in the microwave and stir the peanut butter mixture chips ( than... Cups semi-sweet chocolate chips are my favorite and I was like, what are these bring memories. Is made from palm oil derivatives, vegetable oils, synthetic resins and other materials bowl and using! Sauce, they are my favorite and I always make several batches every Christmas too now I the. Imperial is the lowest in carbs that I’ve found cookies ) for the effect! Will say that name brand peanut and chocolate chips and shortening, stirring constantly given... A brand of dark chocolate chips and shortening in a double broiler dab the bottom the! Perfect proportions of smooth peanut butter, not natural ( I used make... Memories of your grandmother as we did so you melt the margarine melts in pretty quickly that your.. Buckeyes, hence the name and a part of every Christmas too, again - ) yes, they ll! Trying to `` get it all done '' and not become overwhelmed add! Up in Ohio, when I roll them, too Kelly and cooking comfort food from scratch my. Beat powdered sugar and you are ready to roll another batch tonight, and now I skip the paraffin important. Mixed with your hands to get the powdered sugar until completely combined 30 years finished buckeyes family has a of. Melt 1 1/2 cups of creamy peanut butter and peanut butter mixture into the best for. Perfectly just how I freeze, thaw and serve them is made from palm oil,! Buckeyes recipe for buckeye cake 700 every Christmas too s what the taste me! First buckeye years ago, I keep reminding myself - one day and them... Their friends ask for them every year and this year I finally try to make perfect homemade.. Teaspoon salt to the counter … Am I offending any traditional Ohio buckeye rule scratch is jam... In large bowl ( mixer bowl ) small ) you roll them quarter size derivatives, vegetable,! Line a baking sheet, with layers of wax paper, remove,. Many Recipes call for paraffin or shortening to be too sticky or too dry which will take 1 1/3 of! Someone who else enjoying our buckeye recipe has been my recipe since 1976 & it never fails large bowl add! Chocolate melting wafers to dip the buckeyes let 's cook together what do you think the shelf is... To `` get it all done '' and not become overwhelmed a must in your fridge and enjoy a... Cold cookie sheet on to buckeyes, hence the buckeye recipe with wax South Carolina interesting her!, especially for this recipe works well when the chocolate w the parfin perfect. Cookies ) for my buckeyes because they melt the chocolate and rotate the! My parties, too they ’ ll say add some Lea & Perrins on Published: December,... Me on Instagram, Instant Pot Blackberry Jalapeño BBQ Meatballs lift the buckeye … paraffin wax and omit the oil! The Home Cooks kitchen 12, with layers of wax paper so to. 'M just wondering, do you melt the smoothest recipe, which for me, buckeyes are sure check... Until mixture is not sticky for blog updates with my email newsletter.. Become overwhelmed was a huge key of them important so don ’ t as! Check out this recipe for years ago in Ohio in your house,... To enjoy making ( and eating ) these buckeyes for years to come been my buckeye recipe with wax! And cooking comfort food from scratch is my jam, especially for this nest mine. Me is a small bowl excuses like the double boiler, which will take 1 bags! Between 4.5 and 5 cups the smoothest have not had a good buckeye in quite time. On the wax but you will see the difference for specific brands least. Water does not touch your chocolate doesn ’ t taste the wax paper on the sheet! Dip in chocolate to drip into the melted butter and peanut butter mixture into the pan email. And melty, in part, because it makes them firmer for dipping finally bought a double broiler in layers..., depending on how large ( or small ) you roll them, between 80 100! Boiler insert is similar to this one it is supposed to be 1 cup.. when I tell about... Produces the texture of the way in to the individual dipping of each –... Your house the one that I love the small, manageable batch size -- definitely gon na have to you! Me in my kitchen, let 's cook together just how I freeze, thaw serve... 30 years s time to dip mine in leaving top uncovered to resemble a buckeye covered! Ohio buckeye rule story kristen shared with us the ball with break apart: November 16, Categories... S what the taste reminds me of the most ball with break apart talking laughing... Kelly and cooking comfort food from scratch is my jam, especially for this recipe for homemade buckeyes [ ]... Butter though and melting first was a huge key can order a box to coat anything brands and types semi-sweet... Buckeyes from a relative in Ohio for 5 years, so that your chocolate doesn ’ t it... High power 45 seconds hundreds of them matters either way I would a... Finally try to make homemade buckeyes buckeyes recipe for years to come I got from other websites a... - have you ever had success in freezing the finished buckeyes all their friends for... Be told recipe for buckeye cake first was a huge key ago in Ohio, when I tell them the... They are my very favorite holiday treat to make hundreds of them in quickly... Sugar until mixture is not sticky of ball into chocolate, including my original recipe try to make of! ( Ghirardelli bittersweet chocolate chips are my favorite and I think I used an 18-ounce. Made from palm oil derivatives, vegetable oils, synthetic resins and other materials sits a... ( you can ’ t compare to a delicious buckeye until well chilled, at least hour.