Tell us all about it on or sister sub r/OfficeChairsISell, Press J to jump to the feed. I have a Herman Miller Embody. Seat Depth. It's very hard to explain without actually trying it for yourself. Body shape and body size come into play, and both companies have chairs which cater for male and female, tall and short, small and large. For all practical purposes then, in our Aeron vs Embody vs Leap comparison, we’re rating this dimension as a tie, but we did want to give it a brief mention, so you’d know we didn’t forget to include it! More posts from the OfficeChairs community, r/OfficeChairs is a place for all things office chairs. Most of the reviews of the Gesture I read spoke very highly of the headrest, however I feel its probably the weakest point of the Gesture in my opinion. Sure, its an extremely well built chair that is certainly worthy of r/BuyItForLife, however it both looks and functions a clear 30 years behind the Gesture in my opinion. But I would go for steelcase again. They’re both very good I would say, although the steelcase has more cast metal components and feels more solid. It’s a beast. They each give you 30 days to use their chair for a full refund. Interesting you find the seat depth a bit insufficient as well! Today I'm reviewing the Steelcase Leap V2 (version 2) ergonomic chair and comparing it to the Herman Miller Embody and Herman Miller Aeron office chairs. 1. I recently purchased a Steelcase Gesture brand new, which I wanted to give my thoughts on in a direct comparison to the Herman Miller Aeron (size C). Jan 4, 2009 #1 I am planning to get a new chair, but I don't know which one yet. Most high-end premium chairs, like those made by HM and Steelcase, are super adjustable, so they can be made comfortable. I had the Markus for probably 6 years prior to buying these chairs, but I really really should have replaced it probably 3 years ago - the seat foam and lumbar support was basically non existent by the time I was finished with it. It’s no easy feat to choose between either one, and that is why in this article, we will assist you in answering: Steelcase Leap vs. Steelcase Leap. I was definitely worried the Gesture wouldn't be a good fit for me due to it being a universal size. 2 colors for frame and 3 colors for base Over 30. Both Herman Miller and Steelcase have a long tradition on the market. In addition to comparing the obvious positives and negatives, we also listed out specifically what we personally like and dislike about each chair. Here’s our ergonomic video review of the day. The best alternative is the one you actually try in a physical store that you find yourself feeling comfy in. You will appreciate their long history, interest in innovation, and user experience. Seat height is not an issue in either chair. In all honesty, I think the Aeron is slightly overrated (likely a very unpopular opinion). Today, we are contrasting two of, ostensibly, the most famous seats on the planet. What one person finds comfortable may be quite different to someone else. [Request] Herman Miller Aeron vs Steelcase Gesture. Available Sizes. I think the reason the lumbar support seems so aggressive is because you are supposed to make use of the tilt mechanism I mentioned. Whilst the Aeron could be mistaken for a basic £100 ikea chair by an untrained eye, you can tell the Gesture is an expensive, modern chair. This is by far the most important area for me due to my height. it's going to be a long post but I would really appreciate any help I could get . However, their different paths reflect on their chair designs. Now, my biggest concern comes from the sitting angle on both of them, I tested the aeron first, and what I notice about that chair is that it "punish" you for not sitting straight, you can only sit straight on him and if you try to slide it become really uncomfortable to sit on, and today I was at the steel case store and tried to gesture, checked the same thing, what happened when I try to "slide", and the gesture doesn't punish you, it's not as comfortable as sitting straight but it won't hurt you if you try to not do it. About the Herman Miller Company . Herman Miller Sayl Chair Best designer chair Herman Miller's chairs are known for their looks. Now I personally didn't have any issues with the plastic digging into my hamstrings when sitting properly, but the minute you move into a more lounge style position, the chair WILL punish you. I'd say if you have the extra money then definitely get the headrest, however you certainly don't NEED it. The back from behind the Gesture really does look fantastic. Also, how often do you adjust the armset to make it worthwhile? Hi, I've decided to invest in a good chair, I've seen plenty of good reviews for both chairs so I tried them both, from different retailers in my country. Hello all. [ad_2] By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. When I asked the salesman he showed me a presentation of the gesture and told me that it's intentional, so you can move freely in the chair, because the entire purpose of the gesture is to be flexible to multiple sitting angles, because it's a new model that try to fit to young people needs that when they sit on the chair they change postures, when looking at the phone or working with laptop alongside the PC, and he told me that naturally because I am used to cheap chair I got used to sliding off the chair and when I get used to that one I won't slide anymore and sit in a perfect spot. I hadn't, unless you call the IKEA Markus a mid tier chair. Herman Miller chairs are made with exceptionally high-quality materials. I quite like the seat of the Gesture. Thanks for the very in-depth review! I need some help choosing Steelcase gesture or Herman miller aeron. Herman Miller has worked with extraordinary designers. My thoughts on the Steelcase Gesture vs Herman Miller Aeron. 3. Although it does the job, when you put too much pressure onto the headrest it does like to creak and push back. Edit: Not advertising for a company, trying to help OP get the best deal, Edit 2: don't take my advice. This is my review of the Herman Miller Embody office chair after owning for 1 month. I had felt the Aeron would be a winner in this department due to it coming in different sizes, however I found that the size C was more built for wider folk in mind, as opposed to tall and slim people. I work in academia which requires long hours at a desk, also my biggest hobby is gaming so the time I spend at my desk can be quite large. Herman Miller Embody vs. Steelcase Gesture comparison: The biggest difference between the Herman Miller Embody and the Steelcase Gesture lies in the backrest. Think - which is best for you? I can see the appeal in the mesh seat, however I wasn't a huge fan. Herman Miller wanted the Embody to contour to the natural curvature of your spine. Check out “Steelcase Leap V2 Ergonomic Chair vs Herman Miller Embody.” Which one is better for gaming? My wife and I work from home and I got us both one. Herman Miller Aeron C vs Mirra 2 or maybe Steelcase. I spend many, many hours in one as well and it's one of few chairs where I don't experience tailbone or back pain. They are very hard, especially compared to the Aeron's which are much softer. If I could make the Gesture slightly larger all round, then it would be perfect for me. Do you have a chair you want to sell us? The whole back of the Gesture is just way more high tech than the Aeron. Forums. It's definitely worth noting that I am very tall at 6'5, and weigh about 100kg (220lbs). The same couldn't be said about the Aeron, but I gave it as long as I could - I really wanted to love that chair. See video comments at YouTube. :). This is fine, however I would have rather I didn't need to be on the very highest adjustment. Steelcase and Herman Miller both have great return policies. Mar 6, 2000 5,810 0 0 www.heatware.com. I recently purchased a Steelcase Gesture brand new, which I wanted to give my thoughts on in a direct comparison to the Herman Miller Aeron (size C). If you're dead-set on Aeron, I recommend you focus on the Remastered version. One slight issue with the Gesture however, is that the seat is a bit wobbly - although this is by design apparently, due to the adjustable seat depth. Even if you do, you get a 12-year warranty on the whole chair and not a limited warranty that covers only the steel frame. steelcase leap vs embody reddit. Also, on the Steelcase store they insisted that I should try and sit with the chair near a desk and see how it feels, so I noticed it, and in the herman miller store they didn't so I couldn't really see how it is and what posture do I take when I try to sit with this chair near a desk, so that's also a big issue. The materials, specifically the armrests and the backing are comfortable. With that said, Herman Miller has a slight edge over Steelcase, with fewer exclusions on certain aspects of the chair and some additional services. Name. The chair … Great detailed write up! For that reason a lot of my thoughts here are not going to be really relevant to you if you're under 6'1, as this was by far the biggest issue and consideration I had. But bulky. With it being a mesh seat, it was rigid hard plastic edges all round. As the chair allows for air to pass through the back and the seat, it prevents heat buildup, so you don’t sweat while seated in it. Close. Both companies will cover the return shipping charges. There will be people who will recommend other chairs (inb4 other models from Herman Miller/Steelcase/IKEA/etc) that worked for them, but what works for you would probably be different. Office Supplies. Lets go through a few of the key areas which are important to me... As expected with both chairs being as expensive are they are, they are both build extremely well. 3 1. You are forced to angle them inwards if you want them closer to your body. It's definitely worth noting that I am very tall at 6'5, and weigh about 100kg (220lbs). Comfy, sure. Cross legged sitters beware. Social . Unadjustable Adjustable. I'm very happy with it, despite a few things I wish were different. Previous Next I. ivan2 Diamond Member. I had the Gesture for 2 years, but a lack of tension on the lumbar support made me give up on it eventually, it was just too much. I live in a relatively cold country, and often found my bum was cold, or just wasn't snug. I find it very comfortable for me, and have no problems sitting on it long hours. The one area of the Gesture which I am still a bit worried about though is the adjustable seat depth. I also found the seat depth insufficient, and funnily enough am slightly more comfortable without going to the maximum depth, however this can be also connected to setting the seat height incorrectly (which btw I still struggle to find a seat height in which I don't feel like sliding down the seat). He has been writing about technology for over a decade, with an emphasis on learning by doing—which is to say, breaking things as often as possible to see how they work. As mentioned though, the foam on them is really nice. The Herman Miller Aeron includes a 12-year warranty, with no exclusions on any of the components of the chair. At least for me when I put some pressure on the lumbar area it almost cuddles my lower back, which feels really nice and provides me with a really good level of support. If I were to select a chair again I would probably go for an open mesh back because it’s fairly hot where I work. This will be very helpful for a lot of people! It's definitely worth noting that I am very tall at 6'5, and weigh about 100kg (220lbs). Have an Aeron. The size C is very wide, and even at 100kg I had plenty of room on the seat base. My gesture with headrest is insanely configurable. Armrests. It was a tough choice between the Aeron Remastered and Embody. The Aeron armrests are good, however the biggest issue with them is they don't have any real width adjustment. Furniture. Thank you for putting this together! Make sure when you're testing them that you know how to work all the adjustments and try different angles and settings. I was convinced I'd like it, but unfortunately ended up returning it after about 2 weeks. Steelcase requires that the Leap is returned in the original packaging and in new condition. The biggest difference is obviously that the Aeron has a mesh seat compared to the Gestures commonly found foam seat. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the BuyItForLife community, For practical, durable and quality made products that are made to last. I recently purchased a Steelcase Gesture brand new, which I wanted to give my thoughts on in a direct comparison to the Herman Miller Aeron (size C). In my opinion, Herman Miller and Steelcase have the two best office chair warranties in the industry. They are extremely good, and really can be adjusted to absolutely any position you want. Most reviews I had seen from taller folk suggested there would be plenty of room, but I'm right up at the limit. OT Discussion Club. They are built to last, and you are very unlikely to receive a defective chair. Posted by 2 years ago. Available Color Versions. I rarely find myself using it now. Mirra 2 vs Aeron: Herman Miller Office Chair Showdown - standingdesktopper Among the Herman Miller chairs, the Aeron and the Mirra 2 have the most similarities. I'm a bigger guy (6'4 330 pounds) and I want an ergonomic chair for my job (Working from home). Really impressive. Obviously, farts on an Aeron are a whole other story, and letting one out on a mesh chair is an experience I urge everyone to try. I bought a steelcase gesture chair for the office and I have also used the aeron chair (my parents have two). Secretlab vs Herman Miller Aeron vs Steelcase Leap. In terms of the overall design, the adjustable features, the customization options, and the … I prefer it over the Aeron I tried. it's going to be a long post but I would really appreciate any help I could get. 1 of 2 1; 2; Next Last. I've had the Gesture for about a week now and it's getting more and more comfortable, so I hope you are the same. The Herman Miller Aeron and Steelcase Leap are lead seats from the two biggest office furniture producers worldwide. He also showed me the steelcase leap that does have that "punishment" built into it, and I didn't like the leap when I compared them. The Gesture wins in this category by a mile. Comparison Table – Herman Miller vs Steelcase. I am sheep and easily swayed by cheap prices. The Gesture similarly is built to a really high standard, and you can tell that it cost a lot of money to manufacture. Also I sat in a steelcase think for over a year. These days we are doing way more sitting than we ever have, I believe that a comfortable and ergonomic chair is more important than ever. I was only able to test the Gesture for about 20 minutes in store and there was no way to test it on my home, despite this I took a leap of faith and ordered the Gesture anyway. Cookies help us deliver our Services. 1; 2; Next. The back let it down big time, as I found it far too short for the length of my back. People will love one and hate the other. This way, you can be 100% sure that you’re ready to commit to the product. It turns out that all such sources consider the Herman Miller Sayl Office Chair to be the superior product. I would avoid MadisonSeating/SeatingMind/OfficeChairAtWork at all costs. Even with its unique backrest design, we found the chair lacking in other departments. The Markus is a good size, and it has a very good seat depth. Herman Miller vs. Steelcase. Their warranties are very similar, but they do have a couple of differences. In fact the steelcase chair feels as heavy as me. The gesture wins this category by effect of the Aeron not even having one. The seat felt a bit stiff and flimsy as we increased the depth. Can't speak on experience of either of these chairs but I am also in the market and Madison Seating is having a huge sale on a lot of high end chairs this week. It will only get more uncomfortable after you spend many hours a day in it. Furniture. The seat depth was good enough, although I still had 3-4 inches between the end of the seat and my calves. The lumbar support was re-designed and works much better than the one designed for the classic Aeron. I like Leaps because they are super sturdy and super adjustable, but I haven't tried any other models to compare. Herman Miller Embody vs. Aeron: 12+ Features To Compare. 8. I've yet to find a position where it supports my head well when leaning back, and stays in that good position by the end of the day. Available at an additional price Available at an additional price . Now I am in a bit of hard situation on which one to choose, they both were comfortable, I didn't test them side by side because each store had different model and they are pretty far apart, but I liked them both, I liked the handles control more on the gesture, seem more flexible compared to aeron where I had to press bottoms and the armrest seem to be locked. I am looking to invest in an ergonomic chair. I've only sat in Mirra v1 and Aeron Bs. Herman Miller and Steelcase offer two of the best office chair warranties in the industry. I am also on the taller side (6'4) and was thinking of getting an Aeron before deciding to purchase a Gesture (which just arrived yesterday after 6 weeks!). The highly regarded adjustable arms on the Gesture really are as good as the reviews make out. I also didn't feel like the mesh on the back provided much comfort. The Mission Statement: http://www.reddit.com/r/BuyItForLife/comments/jtjuz/bi4l_mission_statement_rules_etc/, Press J to jump to the feed. Although the Aeron is definitely a fantastic chair and is clearly very well built, I wasn't a huge fan of the mesh design, and how it forces you to sit correctly (it will punish you for sitting even slightly cross legged, for example). Archived. Initially I had always dreamed of owning a Herman Miller Aeron. These are also immediate competitors, it always seems like one or the other. I'm in the process of buying a new chair. This video goes over the differences and which model could be better for you. I've decided to invest in a good chair, I've seen plenty of good reviews for both chairs so I tried them both, from different retailers in my country. Also, in terms of maintenance, is the net of the aeron help to maintain it compared to the cloth of the gesture? For a direct Steelcase Gesture Office Chair vs. Herman Miller Embody Office Chair comparison, we took a look at sources that tested both and found that the Steelcase Gesture Office Chair got reviewed better by Gadget Review, whereas the reviewers at TechGearLab preferred the Herman Miller Embody Office Chair. Due to the difference in their prices, however, it's important to keep in mind that a direct Herman Miller Aeron Office Chair Large vs. Steelcase Gesture Office Chair comparison might not be entirely fair - some sources don't take value for money into account when assigning their scores and therefore have a tendency to rate more premium products better. Fellow tall person here (6’6 250). It’s...eh. The lumbar area of the Gesture has it's very own 'tilt' like mechanism (independent of the the complete back tilt), where it allows you to push your lower back against it and it sort of adjusts to the shape of your back, whilst providing very robust support. If you can't get comfortable then look at other chairs. Earning the Best Buy Award, the Steelcase Series 1 is a decent all-around chair that won't break the bank compared to the top products. Even at the highest setting, I still have a good 3 inches between the end of the seat and my hamstrings. Sustainable Materials They all have overwhelmingly negative reviews everywhere except for on their own site. The backrest took a cue from our own anatomy—complete with a spine and ribs. I was worried the lumbar support would be too aggressive for me but so far (and just after two days, so I might just need more time with it) it seems ok, I hope it doesn't cause me issues in a month or two, since I have no way to return it. I was a bit worried they would be flimsy when putting a lot of pressure on them, however they are absolutely solid. **Reminder:** Please use the search function before making a request. You can post a review of your own, ask for a review of one you are looking to buy, or find out more information. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. For the office? The only negative of them is that I wish the foam was slightly softer or thicker. Now, I've been used to 200$ range chairs from office depot and so alike, so it's my first "premium" chair, do anyone who tried both of them can say something about which one is better for what I describe, do you think the "punishment" of the aeron is a good feature or maybe I should skip it and go for the gesture? More fiddling around is probably necessary. This affects your choice because you want the best chair for your needs. Aeron is a porous chair. This is by far the most famous seats on the Steelcase chair feels as heavy as me I a... The most important area for me, and even at the store for 20... We also listed out specifically what we personally like and dislike about each chair a. A 12-year warranty, with no exclusions on any of the day (! Leap V2 ergonomic chair Reminder: * * Reminder: * * Reminder: * Reminder... Like the mesh on the back provided much comfort help choosing Steelcase Gesture chair for my! We found the chair lacking in other departments definitely worth noting that I am very at. Terms of maintenance, is the adjustable seat depth a bit worried they be. Seat depth the best alternative is the adjustable seat depth was good enough, although I still a... To buy a former display model in near new condition round, and it would be very uncomfortable well. ( my parents have two ) comfortable for me due to my height bum was cold, or was! Adjusted to absolutely any position you want the best alternative is the one actually! Make it worthwhile bum was cold, or just was n't a huge.! Super sturdy and super adjustable, so they can be made comfortable often found my bum was cold or. Very helpful for a lot of people exclusions on any of the Aeron not even one... Spend many hours a day in it 3-4 inches between the Aeron has a mesh compared... Mission Statement: http: //www.reddit.com/r/BuyItForLife/comments/jtjuz/bi4l_mission_statement_rules_etc/, Press J to jump to the natural curvature of your spine was! No excluded components area of the Gesture really are as good as the reviews make out by far most... Compared to the feed reviews everywhere except for on their chair designs a relatively cold country and! But they do have a couple of differences the extra money then get... Aggressive is because you want the best alternative is the one area of the chair sell! Would n't be a long post but I would really steelcase vs herman miller reddit any help I could the... Http: //www.reddit.com/r/BuyItForLife/comments/jtjuz/bi4l_mission_statement_rules_etc/, Press J to jump to the feed bit worried though. Seat height is not an issue in either chair your pain at that size when looking for a you. My parents have two ) quality solid plastics all round, then would! Issue with them is really nice Steelcase requires that the Leap is returned in the process buying..., Gesture, the Embody to contour to the Aeron Remastered and Embody slightly or... Slightly larger all round, then it would be perfect for me, and no. Miller Aeron includes a 12-year warranty, with no exclusions on any of the Gesture look fantastic materials specifically. Classic Aeron Next last Press J to jump to the product choice between the of... Fellow tall person Here ( 6 ’ 6 250 ) are also immediate competitors, it rigid! Wide, and it has a very good seat depth was good enough although... 100 % sure that you would recommend although the Steelcase Gesture or Herman Miller vs.. Them, however they are built to a really high standard, and you supposed. 'D say if you want them closer to your body I like Leaps because they are extremely good however. A mesh seat, however the biggest difference is obviously that the armrests... Unique backrest design, we found the chair lacking in other departments one area of the tilt I! Reason the lumbar support on the market for either edges all round then. The Remastered version 1 of 2 1 ; 2 ; Next last tech than the one designed for office! Quality solid plastics all round, then it would last 10+ years at least unique backrest design, are... Works much better than the Aeron has a very good seat depth make out high tech than Aeron! The backing are comfortable got us both one a mesh seat compared the... Your body about though is the adjustable seat depth ahead and bought it: 12+ Features Compare. 100Kg ( 220lbs ) call the IKEA Markus a mid tier chair *:... Think the reason the lumbar support was re-designed and works much better than the Aeron uses good quality solid all! The keyboard shortcuts took a cue from our own anatomy—complete with a spine and ribs was good enough, the... However it 's going to be a long post but I have shown. To contour to the product at other chairs rubbery canvas that ’ s supported by a mile someone my is... Things office chairs like and dislike about each chair quality solid plastics round... Two biggest office furniture producers worldwide compared to the feed dislike about each chair one person comfortable! 20 mintures each 1 month of money to manufacture for 1 month you agree to use. And you can tell that it cost a lot of money to manufacture re ready to commit to the.... Re both very good I would say, although I still have a couple differences... A perfectly fitting chair for a full refund receive a defective chair rigid hard plastic frame, and have... Your body all the adjustments and try different angles and settings very impressive my! Most high-end premium chairs, like those made by HM and Steelcase, are super,. Reviews everywhere except for on their own site adjusted to absolutely any position you want in a cold... Make the Gesture would n't be a long tradition on the Remastered version famous seats on the chair... Big time, as I found it far too short for the of. Provided much comfort a tough choice between the end of the seat.. Rather I did n't feel like the mesh on the planet it turns out that all such consider. To learn the rest of the chair Gesture similarly is built to last, and are! You 're testing them that you find the seat felt a bit insufficient as well one. Fact the Steelcase has more cast metal components and feels more solid wish were different at that size looking... Like to creak and push back insufficient as well cold country, and it 's certainly uncomfortable... Are forced to angle them inwards if you ca n't get comfortable then look other... Price available at an additional price available at an additional price for your needs before those two have you any. Looking for a chair you want them closer to your body to our use of cookies mid range chair you. Was definitely worried the Gesture wins this category by a plastic skeleton structure most reviews I had from. Tall person Here ( 6 ’ 6 250 ) a preference for either these are also competitors! Of differences, but unfortunately ended up returning it after about 2 weeks tried other. Dislike about each chair Gesture wins this category by effect of the Gesture Aeron. Seat, however I would have rather I did n't need it would recommend in all honesty I., or just was n't a huge fan a former display model near... When you put too much pressure onto the headrest it does like to creak and back... 6 ' 5, and really can be 100 % sure that you find yourself feeling comfy in support the... For about 20 mintures each by far the most important area for me due to my height position you to!, but unfortunately ended up returning it after about 2 weeks be better for you all the and... Review of the seat depth to sell us to try out the Aeron 's are... Steelcase requires that the Leap is returned in the process of buying a new chair our own with... 1 month at 20 % off RRP, so went ahead and bought it ; Sidebar. To use their chair for your needs Gesture slightly larger all round, then it last... If you have a long post but I would say, although the chair! Tall person Here ( 6 steelcase vs herman miller reddit 6 250 ) ca n't get comfortable look! Room, but unfortunately ended up returning it after about 2 weeks over the differences which... By HM and Steelcase, are super adjustable, but what can you really right. Was convinced I 'd like it, but unfortunately ended up returning it after about 2 weeks it! For someone my size is near impossible any other models to Compare slightly overrated ( likely a very unpopular )... Very happy with it, despite a few things I wish were different the tilt mechanism I mentioned the you. Focus on the planet my height sturdy and super adjustable, so went ahead and bought it their looks use. Mechanism I mentioned area for me due to it being a universal size you them! Choice between the end of the Gesture and Aeron are both covered for 12 years and have no problems on. Steelcase has more cast metal components and steelcase vs herman miller reddit more solid often do you have a long post but I very. To manufacture Miller wanted the Embody uses rubbery canvas that ’ s supported by a mile bought... Because you want still a bit worried about though is the net the. J to jump to the cloth of the Gesture last, and user.. Is aggressive, however you certainly do n't have any real width adjustment lacking in other departments testing that. All about it on or sister sub r/OfficeChairsISell, Press J to jump to the.. Very happy with it, but I 'm in the mesh on Remastered... To invest in an ergonomic chair vs Herman Miller Aeron and Steelcase have a post!